Table of Contents
Context
- In May, a deadly fire at a coaching centre.
- The rate of suicides in Kota
- Data from the NSSO’s 71st round reveal that more than a quarter of Indian students (a stupendous 7.1 crore) take private coaching.
- Around 12% of a family’s expenses go towards private coaching,
Purpose
- Various coaching centre can be attributed to enhance human capital.
- Imposing a huge emotional cost to society.
- They only help a student to swiftly secure marks in some entrance exam
- To signal merit, exams are only one criterion
- So, coaching institutions exist to help people achieve only one idea of merit.
- The social cost of these institutions outweighs their benefit by far. The industry needs a re-look.
Unregulated spaces
- Hidden behind legislations meant for tiny shops (Shops and Establishment Act) as ‘other’ business, they run an empire of evening incarcerations that arrest creative freedom.
Social capital
- The coaching giants draw an entire generation of young minds
- They ignite psychological disorders in students
- Several court cases on breach of promise of refund are underway.
- The social costs are exacerbated by the absolute disregard
- Society bears the burden
Selling a valueless idea
- To blame the systemic flaws in the implementation of safety laws
- To harp on lapses by the government is to turn a blind eye towards what kind of ethics we are drawing out of our enterprises, particularly those which purport to provide ‘education’.
- Coaching institutions, of course, are not necessarily ethical entities..
- The building in Surat had an illegally constructed terrace.
- It had a wooden staircase that got burnt
- It had no fire safety equipment
- The response of the State government was to shut down all coaching institutions in Gujarat
Need of a policy
- These inspections will only serve a tick-mark purpose.
- Although government measures are more emotional than rational
- Three fire incidents have involved coaching institutions in Gujarat.
Way forward
- What is urgently required is a policy on regulating them.
- Some States have already passed laws
- Existing State laws, however, do not evince a consistent rationale.
- There is also the Private Coaching Centres Regulatory Board Bill, 2016 in discussion.
- While the discourse being triggered is a welcome step, it is now important to ensure regulations that emerge are agile